Raw: [
Most companies and investors are not yet measuring and targeting reductions in Scope 3 value […]]
Companies, Investors Overlooking Major Financial Risks from Unmeasured Scope 3 Emissions: BCG, CDP Report – ESG Today
ESG Investing, sustainable finance & business sustainability news
ESG investing news, analysis, research and information
Top Stories ESG News
Companies
Government
Investors
Regulators
Sustainable Finance
ESG Solutions ESG Tools, Services
Companies Companies
Investors Investors
ESG Disclosure ESG Reporting
Analysis
Regulators
Reports, Studies
Newsfeed
Whitepapers
Events
About About us
Our Team
Advertise With Us
Companies/ Investors/ Reports, Studies
Companies, Investors Overlooking Major Financial Risks from Unmeasured Scope 3 Emissions: BCG, CDP Report
Mark Segal
July 23, 2024
Most companies and investors are not yet measuring and targeting reductions in Scope 3 value chain emissions, leading to significant overlooked and unreported financial risks in their supply chains, according to a new report released by Boston Consulting Group and environmental disclosure system CDP.
For the report, “Scope 3 Upstream: Big Challenges, Simple Remedies,” CDP and BCG analyzed responses to CDP’s 2023 data request. CDP runs a global environmental disclosure system, enabling investors and other stakeholders to measure and track organization’s performance in key environmental sustainability areas including climate change, deforestation, water security, and plastic-related impact. In 2023, a record of more than 23,000 companies disclosed through CDP, up 24% over the prior year, and representing companies worth $67 trillion, or more than 66% of global market capitalization.
Scope 3 emissions typically account for the significant majority of most companies’ emissions footprint. According to the report, companies’ supply chain emissions reported to CDP were on average 26 times higher than their combined Scope 1 and 2 operational emissions.
Despite the disproportionate scale of Scope 3 emissions, however, value chain emissions, occurring outside the direct control of companies, are also typically the most difficult to measure and manage. The report found, for example, that companies are twice as likely to measure Scope 1 and 2 emissions than Scope 3, and 2.4 times more likely to set Scope 1 and 2 emissions reduction targets than Scope 3.
According to the study, the lack of measurement and management of Scope 3 emissions can lead to significant unreported risks for companies and investors, and overlooked material supply chain risks that can adversely impact corporate performance. Based on upstream emissions in 2023 from just the top 3 Scope 3-emitting sectors, manufacturing, retail and materials sectors, for example, the report found an implied carbon liability of more than $335 billion, at the IMF-proposed 2030 $75 floor carbon price.
Despite the potential liability, however, only half of CDP-reporting companies evaluate the financial risks from upstream emissions, yet a third of these companies acknowledge risks to profit from Scope 3 emissions. Similarly, only around a third of investors have investment policies in place mandating climate-related requirements for investee companies, and only 10% require the disclosure of Scope 3 supply chain emissions.
Sherry Madera, Chief Executive Officer of CDP, said:
“Scope 3 data is no longer a nice to have. Financial markets stakeholders, from corporates to investors, must scale up the level of accountability and action to match the scale of supply chain emissions. As global standards and incoming mandatory reporting rules require Scope 3, this disclosure will increasingly affect core business and portfolio success both at home and abroad.”
The report identified 3 factors, out of more than 20 examined, that emerged as statistically significant to target setting and action on Scope 3 emissions, including having in place a “climate-responsible board,” supplier engagement and internal carbon pricing. Companies disclosing through CDP that had a board with climate oversight and at least one climate-competent board member, for example, were found to be 4.8x more likely to have a 1.5°C-aligned transition plan with a Scope 3 target, according to the report. Similarly, companies that engage with suppliers on climate-related issues, and those that have adopted an internal carbon price were found to be nearly 7x as likely, and 4x as likely, respectively, to have a 1.5°C-aligned transition plan and a Scope 3 target.
Overall, the report found that 34% of companies have a climate-responsible board, 41% are engaging with suppliers, and 14% are using an internal carbon price.
Diana Dimitrova, Managing Director and Partner at BCG said:
“Supply chain emissions are, on average, 26 times greater than a corporate’s operational emissions. Hence, aligning climate ambitions across the supply chain helps drive a disproportionate impact on emissions. Yet, these emissions continue to be overlooked by corporates and investors alike. A $335bn+ liability is overlooked. The responsibilities and incentives to act on Scope 3 emissions for these two groups converge on risk management, and their oversight bodies must push for emission reduction. Lack of management oversight on upstream emissions exposes boards to regulatory, reputation, and operational risks.
“Boards have a fiduciary responsibility to act on climate-related risks, while investors must demand transparency and price in risk. Addressing Scope 3 emissions is therefore a shared responsibility.”
Click here to access the report.
Mark founded ESG Today following a 20 year career in investment management and research. Prior to founding ESG Today, Mark worked at Delaney Capital Management (DCM) in Toronto, Canada, most recently as the firm’s head of U.S. equities. While at DCM, Mark was part of the firm’s ESG team, responsible for evaluating and tracking the sustainability factors impacting portfolio companies, and assessing the suitability of companies for portfolio inclusion. Mark also spent several years in the sell-side research industry, covering the technology and services sectors. Mark holds an MBA from Columbia University in New York, a BBA from the Schulich School of Business at York University in Toronto, and is a CFA charterholder.
Related Posts
Companies /
DHL, Envision Launch Green Logistics Partnership
Investors /
Green Impact Exchange Files to Launch First-Ever Sustainability-Focused Stock Exchange in U.S.
Reports, Studies /
74% of Public Companies Plan to Invest in Sustainability Reporting Technology and Tools Over Next Year: Deloitte Survey
‹ Eni in Talks to Sell Stake in Mobility Transformation Unit to KKR at up to $13.5 Billion Valuation
ESG Today Newsletter – Subscribe
Subscribe to the ESG Today NewsletterJoin our mailing list for the latest breaking ESG investment news!
LevelC-LevelSVP / EVPDirector / VPManager / SupervisorMid or Entry LevelFreelance / ContractStudent / InternRetiredOther
FunctionAccounting & FinanceBusiness Development & SalesCustomer SupportFacilitiesHR & TalentInvestingLegalMarketing & CommunicationsOperationsR & DProcurement & ContractingSupply Chain & DistributionSustainabilityStrategyTechnologyOther
SUBSCRIBE!
You have Successfully Subscribed!
Sustainable Finance
Masdar Issues $1 Billion Green Bond to Invest in Greenfield Renewable Energy Projects
HSBC Launches New Infrastructure Finance Unit to Pursue Low Carbon Transition Opportunities
Energy Impact Partners Appoints Jeff McDermott as Head of Strategic Finance
Demeter Invests in H2 Green Steel
Government
U.S. Announces Over $4 Billion Funding for Projects to Reduce GHG Emissions Across Key Sectors
Von der Leyen Pledges New Clean Industrial Deal in New Mandate as EU Commission President
Canada to Invest up to $1 Billion in Oil Sands Carbon Capture Projects
UK Government Appoints Carbon Trust CEO Chris Stark to Lead New Clean Energy Transition Team
Categories
Select Category
Business Wire
ESG News
Analysis
Climate
Companies
Energy Transition
Environment
ESG Reporting
ESG Tools, Services
Executive Moves
Governance
Government
Guest Posts
Investors
M&A
New funds & products
Platforms & Markets
Private Equity & Venture Capital
Professional bodies
Regulators
Reports, Studies
Social
Social & Governance
Sustainable Finance
Welcome
Back to Top
Home
About us
Disclosure, cookies & privacy policy
© ESG Today 2024
Don’t miss the top ESG stories!Join the ESG Today daily newsletter and get all the top ESG stories, like this one.
Subscribe now below!
LevelC-LevelSVP / EVPDirector / VPManager / SupervisorMid or Entry LevelFreelance / ContractStudent / InternRetiredOther
FunctionAccounting & FinanceBusiness Development & SalesCustomer SupportFacilitiesHR & TalentInvestingLegalMarketing & CommunicationsOperationsProcurement & ContractingR & DStrategySupply Chain & DistributionSustainabilityTechnologyOther
SUBSCRIBE!
You have Successfully Subscribed!
Never miss the latest breaking ESG investment news. Get ESG Today’s newsletter today!
Subscribe Now
c
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy